Perkins and Will and HBN Advise Against Using Antimicrobial Building Products
Perkins and Will and the Healthy Building Network (HBN) have issued a statement that claims that building products with antimicrobial treatments are not proven to be an effective mean of controlling the spread of the novel coronavirus.
In response to growing concerns over COVID-19, the organizations reaffirmed the conclusion of their March 2017 white paper on antimicrobial building products: Antimicrobial additives have not been proven to have the health benefits they promote, and alternatives should be sought wherever possible.
“We’ve been receiving an uptick in questions from clients and colleagues across every sector about how to prevent the spread of pathogens like SARS-CoV-2, which is the virus that causes COVID-19, in the built environment,” says Mary Dickinson, associate principal and co-director of the Material Performance Lab at Perkins and Will.
“As champions of material health and transparency, we knew a part of our response needed to address the questions surrounding the use of materials with antimicrobials. While we published a robust white paper on the matter in 2017, we needed to ask if the science and governmental feedback was still valid under the current circumstances. It was important to put out research-backed guidance and best practices on this matter as soon as possible.”
According to the organizations, no scientific evidence exists that demonstrates additional human health benefits from antimicrobial additives in building products and materials, despite marketing claims suggesting otherwise. Such products include textiles, furnishings, flooring, tiles, and other surfaces and interior finishes.
“During this time of uncertainty, we have to focus on science to guide our decisions,” says HBN Chief Research Officer and toxicologist Teresa McGrath. “There is no evidence that the addition of antimicrobials to building products lowers the rate of infection or that they lead to a healthier population.”
The organizations additionally state that certain antimicrobials, such as nanosilver, are considered toxic to humans and to entire aquatic ecosystems.
Antimicrobial additives have been shown to leach out of materials during use, entering drains and water treatment facilities. Since wastewater treatment sludge is spread as crop fertilizer in some jurisdictions, contamination of the surrounding environment becomes a risk.
“It can be challenging to completely avoid antimicrobials if manufacturers provide little or no transparency into their products’ ingredients,” says Max Richter, senior associate and co-director of the Perkins and Will Material Performance Lab. “But designers and architects can make more informed decisions through resources such as the Perkins and Will Transparency portal and Precautionary List, as well as HBN’s Pharos website.”
Another negative consequence of using building products with antimicrobial additives is the false sense of security they may create when overly relied upon as a part of an infection control plan: In some cases, the use of these products creates the potential for less-diligent facility maintenance.
Marketing claims that antimicrobial building products reduce the transmission of disease are scientifically unfounded. Perkins and Will and HBN reveal that the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) say human health is best ensured through proper cleaning practices—such as wiping down surfaces with soap and water before treating them with a disinfectant approved by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)—and through proper maintenance of building engineering systems.
Until the CDC issues guidance regarding the efficacy of building products treated with antimicrobials, Perkins and Will and HBN advise design professionals to avoid their use whenever possible.
“As we return to our offices, schools, and public spaces, the CDC and public health authorities are identifying the proper strategies to keep people healthy,” says HBN founder Bill Walsh. “Antimicrobial building products are not one of those strategies.”